TurboTax vs. an Accountant: When Should You Stop Doing Your Own Taxes?

When it comes to TurboTax vs accountant, which option is actually better for filing your taxes? As a tax and accounting firm, we obviously have some bias, but the truth is not everyone needs to hire a professional. For some taxpayers, doing your own taxes with software like TurboTax can work perfectly well.

The right choice ultimately depends on how complicated your tax situation is. Our individual tax checklist can help you understand what you’ll need to prepare, whether you decide to file on your own or work with a professional.

Should I Do My Own Taxes? (When Software Is Enough)

If your tax situation is relatively simple, doing your own taxes may work perfectly fine. Someone with a single W-2, a standard deduction, and no side income may be fine using TurboTax. This can also apply to those with straightforward investments or brokerage accounts.

For simple returns, eligible taxpayers may also be able to file through IRS Free File or other IRS filing options. Not every tax situation requires professional help, and knowing when you can safely DIY is part of making the right choice.

When DIY Starts Costing You More Than It Saves

When comparing TurboTax vs CPA services, the decision becomes more important as your financial situation gets more complicated. If you’re wondering is it worth paying someone to do your taxes, consider professional help if you have self-employment or gig income, rental property, equity compensation, a multi-state move, a marriage or divorce, or a letter from the IRS.

Tax software can answer the questions you enter, but a professional can ask questions you may not have known to consider. Missed deductions and filing errors can quietly compound and may eventually require tax relief. As discussed in “What Would a Tax Attorney Never Do on Their Own Tax Return?”, even tax professionals recognize situations where handling everything yourself may not be the best approach.

What Working With a Pro Actually Looks Like

Working with a tax professional goes beyond filing your return in April. A professional can review prior returns, help plan for estimated payments and entity choices, and answer tax questions throughout the year. At Boxelder, licensed attorneys, CPAs, and enrolled agents work together under one roof, backed by an A+ BBB rating. You’ll speak directly with a licensed tax professional, not a salesperson. Contact us to discuss your tax situation and get the support you need moving forward.

Group 28 Created with Sketch.

About the Author

A company founder standing by a mountain range

Dave Weishaus

Co-Founder, Tax Advisor, Business Consultant

Dave Weishaus, co-founder of Boxelder Consulting and Tax Relief, has over 20 years of small business consulting and tax advisory experience. He has a law degree from the University of Baltimore and completed undergrad from Johns Hopkins University with a focus on International Business and East Asian Studies. Now, Dave specializes in financial consulting, tax planning, and general administrative services. Dave’s favorite part of working at Boxelder Consulting is working with start-ups and sharing in the excitement of launching a new venture. Dave is the proud father of Moses, a gentle 200lb St. Bernard.

Group 28 Created with Sketch.

Take the Next Step

Get a free, no strings attached, thorough analysis of your tax liabilities.

Request a Consultation